Games
Problems
Go Pro!

From MI to MU

Reference > Mathematics > Slick Math
 

This is an interesting little problem I ran into back when I was in high school: Change the string of letters 'MI' to the string 'MU', using the following rules.

  • If a string ends with 'I', 'U' can be added ('MI' 
    can be changed to 'MIU')
  • Three 'I's in succession can be changed to a 'U' ('MUIII' can be changed to 'MUU')
  • The string 'Mx' (where x is any sequence of letters) can be changed to 'Mxx' ('MUIU' can be changed to 'MUIUUIU')
  • Two 'U's in succession can be deleted ('MIUU' can be changed to 'MI')

Solution

The annoying thing about this problem is this: It can't be solved. I had a friend who spent several hours attempting to solve it before bringing it to me; he was not happy to find out the problem was unsolvable. So how do I know it is unsolvable?

Only two of the rules alter the number of I's: the second rule decreases the number of of I's by 3, and the third rule doubles the number of I's. 

If the number of I's is not a multiple of three, neither subtracting 3 or doubling will result in a multiple of three. Since 0 is a multiple of three, we can never get rid of all the I's. 

Isn't that slick?

Questions

1.
Could the problem be solved if the third rule was that 'Mx' can be changed to 'Mxxx'?
2.
What if the second rule was that two I's can be changed to a U?
3.
What if the first rule was that if a string ends with I, IU can be added?
Assign this reference page
Click here to assign this reference page to your students.
Checkerboards and DominoesCheckerboards and Dominoes
The Reciprocal SeriesThe Reciprocal Series
 

Blogs on This Site

Reviews and book lists - books we love!
The site administrator fields questions from visitors.
Like us on Facebook to get updates about new resources
Home
Pro Membership
About
Privacy